Truly, I'll finish this and be done with The Dixie Chicks. This, however, was all just too juicy to pass up.
For the London Telegraph, The Chicks gave an interview. If they have expressed similar things in the US media, I haven't seen it. Again, we see the massive expression of their, er, bravery....
The Chicks can't hide their disgust at the lack of support they received from other country performers. "A lot of artists cashed in on being against what we said or what we stood for because that was promoting their career, which was a horrible thing to do," says Robison.
So, what The Chicks did had nothing to do with promoting their career. So all those appearances for Rolling Stone, Entertainment Weekly, et al, had nothing to do with promoting their career. I get it. They speak with courage, others exploit. Sure.
Maybe they are familiar with the phrase: Good for the goose, good for the gander. Their accusation flies both ways. If we are to take their critique of Bush and Iraq as honest, then why can't we take the critique of them as honest? Oh, that's right, if you support Bush and the war you are, by definition, a lying bastard. I keep forgetting that....
"A lot of pandering started going on, and you'd see soldiers and the American flag in every video. It became a sickening display of ultra-patriotism."
First, let's understand what "pandering" means, aside from the traditional definition (to pander is to perform the job of a pimp, setting up customers for whores). In its current usage "to pander" or "pandering" means you are playing false to a crowd. That is, you are promoting ideas that you don't believe in but that your crowd does. You pretend support in order to gain favor from the crowd.
Remember, Maines made her original statement before a London audience, not a Texas audience. Almost seems like...pandering....
But not really because it's clear that Maines truly believes in what she said, so she wasn't pandering. When she makes the accusation here, though, she's saying that the artists using the flag and soldiers in their videos don't believe in the mission, the troops, or the country, and thus are pandering. Again, it's an easy accusation but is she saying that, oh, Tobey Keith is lying when he sings in support of the troops or the country, that he doesn't really believe in what he's singing? Again, they want it both way. Anyone who opposes Bush, the war, etc., is speaking the truth, while anyone who supports Bush, the war, etc., is pandering.
"The entire country may disagree with me, but I don't understand the necessity for patriotism," Maines resumes, through gritted teeth. "Why do you have to be a patriot? About what? This land is our land? Why? You can like where you live and like your life, but as for loving the whole country… I don't see why people care about patriotism."
We start with a few definitions of patriotism that you can find on the Web:
- love of country and willingness to sacrifice for it; "they rode the same wave of popular patriotism"; "British nationalism was in the air and patriotic sentiments ran high"
[wordnet.princeton.edu/perl/webwn] - Patriotism is a feeling of love and devotion to one's own homeland (patria, the land of one's fathers). This article surveys the concept of patriotism from the viewpoints of history, politics, ethics, and biology.
[en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patriotism] - To show love, support, and sacrifice for one's country.
[www.nps.gov/mana/education/vocab.htm]
To be generous, I'd say that Maines is young and ignorant. Why do people care about patriotism? That depends a great deal on how much you feel you have benefitted by being a citizen of your country. I would imagine that if you had been born in Russia during the Stalin era you might not feel very patriotic, given his penchant for purges.
On the other hand, if you lived in a country that afforded you the opportunity to pursue your musical dreams, to rise to the top in your field, to have your music played throughout the country and around the world.... In other words, if you were The Dixie Chicks, wouldn't you have some love for the country that gave you birth and afforded you the opportunity to become what you are?
Well, apparently not, and she doesn't "understand the necessity" for patriotism. Given that, I can assume that if ever in the future I hear the phrases "I support the troops" or "I love my country" or anything similar coming from the mouth of Natalie Maines, she is pandering, i.e., lying through her teeth.
Oh, and a clarification re The Chicks new producer....
The recruitment of Rick Rubin as producer, the man who rejuvenated Johnny Cash, the Red Hot Chili Peppers, Neil Diamond and others, is guaranteed to extend the Chicks' appeal, though it would be disappointing if the album's thoughtful range of subject matter (from IVF to Alzheimer's) was overshadowed by the Bush episode.
I don't see hip hop on the list, but Rubin may handle that, too. And I love that word, "rejuvenated". Did any of those performers need rejuvenation? Do The Chicks need rejuvenating? Interesting.
Comments